Cost Plus vs Fixed Price Building Contracts in NSW: What Actually Protects You

Builder signing a building contract on a clipboard at a Sydney construction site, with a second contract, blueprints, and the Sydney Harbour Bridge visible in the background

Before you sign anything with a builder, the type of contract you’re signing matters almost as much as the price itself. In NSW, the two main structures, fixed price and cost plus, put very different amounts of risk on you as the homeowner. Here’s the real difference, and what the law actually requires either way.

The Core Difference

A fixed price contract sets a single total figure for the job upfront. Barring agreed variations, that’s what you pay, and the risk of a cost blowout sits with the builder. A cost plus contract works the opposite way: you pay the actual cost of materials and labour, plus the builder’s margin or fee on top. The certainty you get with cost plus isn’t on the total, it’s only on the builder’s percentage or fee. Everything else can move.

That difference also changes how much ongoing involvement the contract expects from you. A cost plus arrangement typically comes with more paperwork and more decisions for you to sign off on as the job progresses, since you’re effectively underwriting the actual spend rather than paying a number agreed in advance.

Both Contract Types Sit Under the Same Law

Whichever structure you choose, you’re still protected by the same framework. Both fixed price and cost plus contracts for residential work fall under the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW), and the same statutory warranties apply regardless of which one you sign. The difference is in how the price is structured and disclosed, not in which consumer protections apply.

For a cost plus contract specifically, the contract has to spell out exactly how the final price will be calculated, not just state that you’ll pay “cost plus a fee” with no further detail. If a cost plus contract you’re shown doesn’t clearly explain its own pricing methodology, that’s worth questioning before you sign.

The Rules That Apply No Matter Which You Choose

A few protections apply across the board, and they’re worth knowing regardless of which contract structure you end up with:

Licensing. Anyone doing residential building work valued over $5,000 has to be licensed through NSW Fair Trading. Always check this before signing anything.

Deposit cap. For contracts over $20,000, the maximum deposit a builder can request is 10% of the contract price, and they can’t take that deposit, or start work, until they’ve given you a current Home Building Compensation Fund certificate. We’ve covered what that certificate actually covers and how to check one in more detail separately.

Cooling-off period. For residential building contracts over $20,000, section 7BA of the Home Building Act gives you a statutory right to rescind the contract within 5 business days of signing or receiving your copy, without penalty, and this right can’t be excluded by the contract’s own terms. If a signed contract doesn’t include the required cooling-off statement, that’s a problem with the contract itself, not just paperwork.

Where Fixed Price Contracts Aren’t Always Fully Fixed

It’s worth knowing that a fixed price contract can still contain cost plus elements hiding inside it. Provisional sums and prime cost items, placeholder allowances for things like tiling, fittings, or finishes that haven’t been selected yet, effectively turn that portion of an otherwise fixed price contract into a cost plus arrangement for that specific item. If your “fixed price” quote has a long list of provisional sums, ask what happens if the actual cost comes in above the allowance, because that’s exactly the scenario a true fixed price contract is supposed to protect you from.

Which One Actually Suits Your Project

Fixed price suits a project where the design and inclusions are genuinely locked in before the contract is signed, you’re trading some flexibility for budget certainty. Cost plus can make sense on a project with a lot of unknowns going in, a renovation where the existing structure might reveal surprises, for instance, where a builder might otherwise have to price in a large contingency just to protect themselves under a fixed number. For most custom home builds and knockdown rebuilds where the design is settled before construction starts, fixed price gives homeowners the clearer, more predictable outcome.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the main difference between fixed price and cost plus contracts?

A fixed price contract sets one total figure upfront, with the builder carrying the risk of cost overruns. A cost plus contract has you paying the actual cost of the work plus the builder’s margin, so the final total can move.

Are cost plus contracts legal in NSW?

Yes. Both fixed price and cost plus contracts are regulated under the Home Building Act 1989, with the same statutory warranties applying to both. A cost plus contract just has to clearly set out how the final price will be calculated.

Can a builder ask for more than a 10% deposit?

Not for contracts over $20,000. The deposit is capped at 10% of the contract price, and the builder has to provide a current Home Building Compensation certificate before taking it or starting work.

Do I get a cooling-off period on a building contract?

For residential building contracts over $20,000, yes. You have 5 business days from signing, or from receiving your copy of the contract, to rescind it without penalty under section 7BA of the Home Building Act, and this right can’t be signed away.

Can a “fixed price” contract still have variable costs in it?

Yes, if it includes provisional sums or prime cost items for finishes or fittings that aren’t finalised yet. Those specific allowances work like a cost plus arrangement even inside an otherwise fixed price contract.

Materials selection is often where provisional sums show up. Our comparison of Hebel vs brick covers one example of a material choice that can affect your final contract price either way.

Beyond the contract itself, it’s worth knowing that NSW’s new Building Approvals Bill will change some of the terminology and process around approvals once it commences, which is worth factoring into any contract timeline.

If you’re planning a new build or knockdown rebuild and want clear, fixed-price contracts with no surprises, our guide to knockdown rebuild services covers how we structure projects from day one.